Gordon boateng leaves brimsdown

[Football Man]

Can we not just refer to his Wikipedia entry? Perhaps someone should write a letter to the NLP suggesting they do the same!

[Horace]

Originally Posted By: Rhodes

Originally Posted By: HTFCew

Wasn't it his coaching achievements Spidermanor asked about?

As 'the great one' has worked all over the World it will take time to compile a list of all his Coaching achievements in the game so far, try to be patient.

Let's just start with what he's achieved at Haringey and Kentish Town - that shouldn't take you long!

[Rhodes]

Originally Posted By: Spidermanor

I also see your quest to reunite him with the son who wants nothing to do with him has suffered a blow with the announcement of the Israel squad for the England game.

Spidermanor - Further to your earlier post can I just ask what your 'reliable' source of information is as according to Sky News Toto is very much part of the Israel squad:

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,11966_2704018,00.html

[Spidermanor]

Originally Posted By: Rhodes

Originally Posted By: Spidermanor

I also see your quest to reunite him with the son who wants nothing to do with him has suffered a blow with the announcement of the Israel squad for the England game.

Spidermanor - Further to your earlier post can I just ask what your 'reliable' source of information is as according to Sky News Toto is very much part of the Israel squad:

http://www.skysports.com/story/0,19528,11966_2704018,00.html

Obviously the same one you used when you agreed with earlier when you said:

"Yes it would appear that Toto isn't in the Israel squad for Saturday's crucial encounter at Wembley but there must be good reason for that, I believe he is injured"

Now, please stop trying to get out of answering a perfectly valid question by trying to change the subject. You're oh so predictable old boy.

[Rhodes]

Spidermanor - I'm afraid I've lost you, why did you tell me Toto wasn't in the Israel squad for Saturday or was it just a wind up, you're always so serious, in an old fashioned school teacher fashion, that I didn't think you were capable of wind ups.

[Spidermanor]

Ahh rhodesys excuse no 442: pretend to not understand a post in order to gain time and/or divert attention.

 

Try again rhodesy and answer the question you've been asked. Stop playing for time in the hope the embarrassing situation you find yourself in goes away, you really are so obvious. Just to remind you here's the question again:

 

"list Mr Temiles coaching achievements here so we can compare them to Mr Boatangs"

 

Quite simple really and to make it even easier for you, and to make it properly comparable to Mr Boatang's championship winning credentials. I'll only ask for Mr Temile's list of 'achievements' in English non-league football. Remember you promised an answer today.

 

Oh and to answer your earlier stupidity, Tamuz was obviously added to the squad late in the same way Heskey was to the England squad. Which is why when you looked yesterday, you thought he wasn't going to be in it and made up some nonsense about an injury.

 

Hmm, Tamuz and Heskey actually thats quite an apt comparison isn't it old boy.

 

 

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

why do the usual suspects have to use other people as a bat to hit Rhodes with?

It does you guys no credit when you demand a list of a coaches achievements so you can compare them with anothers.

You are only doing it to have a go at Rhodes.

Think of the individuals involved, please.

[Wader]

TheSpursFan - all well and good, but the questions to Cec were borne out of his repetitive digs at Gordon Boateng with little justification. A comparison with someone he staunchly supports is thus now a valid line of questioning. I'm sorry, but Cec has brought this one upon himself and now refuses to continue the discussion.

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

I dont believe that Rhodes questioning of one coaches loyalty or stickabilty, or experience, should lead to questions about anothers.

 

Where's the humanity gone? Isn't it hard enough for Mr Temille now with all the publicity over his son's arrival, without us having a dig at his coaching credentials?

 

 

And I think this is an unforunate comment from Spider

"Hmm, Tamuz and Heskey actually thats quite an apt comparison isn't it old boy."

 

 

[Spidermanor]

More predictable comments from the stooge, designed to allow rhodesy to wriggle out of justifying his comments, wheres the decency or humanity in that.

 

Do all spurs fans have the a moral code which allows them to believe that making disparaging remarks (without justification) about others is acceptable. Actually they probably do, looking at the treatment of poor old Martin Jol recently.

 

How is the Tamuz comparison with Heskey unfortunate, the last time a saw Tamuz play he ran around, unsettled the defence, got into good positions and then missed some easy chances. A valid comparison methinks.

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

you have lost your sense of perspective, peoples private lives and family situations should not be a focus of fun or used to score forum points on another individual.

 

However thanks for clarifying the comparison. I still wouldnt think the points you make about them are unique to the two strikers mentioned.

 

There are enough people already attacking or bringing Rhodes to book over his comments, so I dont always feel the need to add to it.

[Football Man]

Originally Posted By: thespursfan

Isn't it hard enough for Mr Temille now with all the publicity over his son's arrival

All of it emanating from a single source, I think you'll find!

[Wader]

Originally Posted By: thespursfan

I dont believe that Rhodes questioning of one coaches loyalty or stickabilty, or experience, should lead to questions about anothers.

By this comment I take it you agree with Rhodes in his views of Gordon Boateng. Instead of hiding behind his large and resting case, why don't you just say that outright and join the discussion openly and frankly instead of bleating for your pal from the sidelines?

I have no particular problem with Cec, apart from bringing him to book and explaining himself over his constant anti-Boateng comments. By others making comparisons with someone he idolises I hope that it will demonstrate the lightweight nature of a substantive part of his argument and how unjustified it is. It's called debate.

If Cec wants to make comments about individuals that is fine, but he has to be prepared to back them up when questioned by others. If he isn't prepared to do that then his views are frankly worthless.

[Rhodes]

Originally Posted By: Spidermanor

How is the Tamuz comparison with Heskey unfortunate

I will respond to the recent posts on this thread later when I have more time however I also picked up on this particular quote from Spidermanor. All I can say is ask me at 6.50 on Saturday evening why it's unfortunate and I will tell you then.

[Spidermanor]

Originally Posted By: thespursfan

you have lost your sense of perspective, peoples private lives and family situations should not be a focus of fun or used to score forum points on another individual.

However thanks for clarifying the comparison. I still wouldnt think the points you make about them are unique to the two strikers mentioned.

There are enough people already attacking or bringing Rhodes to book over his comments, so I dont always feel the need to add to it.

Well if I may as to be so bold as to quote rhodesy

"what a fascinating post"

Would you care to elucidate on what perpective I've lost, and where in the question "please list Mr Temiles coaching achievements" I'm using a family situation to score points.

If you are refering to Toto Tamuz, I'm afraid he is fair game. Rhodesy is the one who has posted links to a dozen different negative press reports about young Tamuz's refusal to see his father. If he continues to try and manipulate a situation he has no right to be involved in, he can expect flak to come his way.

Now back the subject at hand, wheres that list rhodesy?

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

I dont share Rhodes view of Mr Boateng as I have no idea who he is outside of the comments on here. I have no particular interest in the gentleman, or his career. I wish him well.

 

You guys are all capable of debating his football credentials and are very welcome to do so in my book.

 

I dont have a problem with you asking Rhodes to justify his comments.

 

 

 

I just feel every now and again some of the members get so carried away with an anti-Rhodes feeling that they run the risk of missing the target.

 

In doing so they may harm those around him.

 

I realise I have no right to lecture people, but I enjoy reading this forum and occasionally feel the need to query whats going on.

 

 

[Spidermanor]

Originally Posted By: Rhodes

Originally Posted By: Spidermanor

How is the Tamuz comparison with Heskey unfortunate

I will respond to the recent posts on this thread later when I have more time however I also picked up on this particular quote from Spidermanor. All I can say is ask me at 6.50 on Saturday evening why it's unfortunate and I will tell you then.

Hmm, how long does it take to type: "he hasn't actually achieved anything yet. I'm sorry to have made that unfortunate comment about Gordon Boateng".

Oh and I'm glad to see you're still supporting the country of residence of the son of your coach, even though he wants nothing to do with his father. Or are you just manipulating the situation to try and blag a free ticket?

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

spidermanor i would refer you to your post 9.47 yesterday, and I see you are still at it.

 

 

[Spidermanor]

And I refer you to my post of 11.47 this morning. Your move old boy.

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

I think we have both summarised our positions adequately for now spidermanor, thank you for reading.