FA Cup banned player

[Karen Browne]

What an odd world we now live in - back in the good old days football was played on grass not paper

[Dirtyclaret]

Against London Apsa, they brought on a sub that was actually named in the starting 11.

Would thus just be a telling off?

[Whitley Bay]

FA Cup Rule 15e. A player shall not play for more than one Club in the Competition in the same season.

 

FA Cup Rule 15g. A substitute who does not play in a match is entitled to play for another Club in the Competition in the same season.

 

Therefore, a (non-playing) substitute is deemed not to have played and so

 

FA Cup Rule 16b. Subject to 16c. below, where an ineligible player plays for a club in a Competition match, the Professional Game Board shall remove the club from the Competition, and may impose further penalties against the club.

 

does not apply.

Edited September 14, 2013 by Whitley Bay

[Dirtyclaret]

Nice font.

 

Does not answer my query. Ours was in the vase btw

[Big J R]

Nice font.

 

Does not answer my query. Ours was in the vase btw

 

 

Whitley does go to a very nice Church  !!

 

Edited September 14, 2013 by Big J R

[seanmacrook]

I hope thurrock look at this given how they where treated.

[Whitley Bay]

Nice font.

 

Does not answer my query. Ours was in the vase btw

It was not intended to answer your (subsequent) query, but like Pete the Greek, it tried to answer the original query regarding Barton Rovers.

 

p.s. I'm glad you like the font.........

[Whitley Bay]

Against London Apsa, they brought on a sub that was actually named in the starting 11.

Would thus just be a telling off?

I believe the relevant section of the rules of the FA Vase is Rule 15c., which states "..prior to the substitution being made the Club must identify to the Match Officials the number of the player out and the player in, in accordance with the Official Team Sheet...".

 

Therefore, unless I'm mistaken, the substitution should not have been allowed by the Match Officials. Where it goes from there, is not clear in the rules.........

 

[Whitley Bay]

Whitley does go to a very nice Church  !!

 

You obviously know something I don't!!

[former no 9]

You obviously know something I don't!!

Also, if a substitute in the FA cup final doesn't make it onto the pitch he still gets a medal, in my eyes the FA were out of order not awarding the game to us.