FA Vase/Rye lodge complaint to FA

[Savagebee]

Already being discussed on the FA Vase thread

 

have'nt looked at that thread yet

[Winslow Boy]

So Amersham removed for fielding an ineligable player. How did Rye know?

[Karen Browne]

So Amersham removed for fielding an ineligable player. How did Rye know?

 

Certainly looks that way

http://ryeunited.freeforums.org/news-vase-t410.html

[Horace]

and I see that they've even got the cheek to ponder if they get the prize money. Only a few clubs have someone who checks out the credentials of everyone in their opponents' squad just in case they lose the game. Won't be cheering Rye on in the next round.

[Mississippi Burning]

and I see that they've even got the cheek to ponder if they get the prize money. Only a few clubs have someone who checks out the credentials of everyone in their opponents' squad just in case they lose the game. Won't be cheering Rye on in the next round.

 

Pardon? Rumour has it Amersham played 3 or 4 players under assumed names and have, more than likely, done the same in previous rounds too.

 

Are you condoning that behaviour and saying it shouldnt be revealed? and that Rye are somehow in the wrong?

 

Astonishing.

Edited November 24, 2012 by Mississippi Burning

[Horace]

If those rumours are correct, I withdraw my comments unreservedly. Had assumed that it was a case of the odd uptied player not noticed by the home secretary. Will be interested to learn more - if it was as you say, Amersham will probably be barred from net season's comp.

Edited November 24, 2012 by Horace

[Munchkin]

If you're stupid enough to have photos of players on your website then play someone else under their name you deserve to get caught.

[No13]

If you're stupid enough to have photos of players on your website then play someone else under their name you deserve to get caught.

It's fraud also as they tried to gain financial income in an inappropriate manner.

Stick them in Division 2 is what the SSML should do as they have brought shame on the league, plus they're sh1t too

[Winslow Boy]

If those players are available to play why not just sign them?!!!!

[Mississippi Burning]

it would be interesting to see whether they have been doing it in league games too.

[Winslow Boy]

it would be interesting to see whether they have been doing it in league games too.

Well yes indeed. What about previous vase ties too?

[Rhodes]

If those rumours are correct, I withdraw my comments unreservedly

Horace - You soon changed your tune!

[Winslow Boy]

 

Horace - You soon changed your tune!

Because he acknowledged he was wrong when presented with the facts and apologised. I know that's a difficult concept for you to grasp which in a way is ironic because you never have the facts and are frequently wrong

[Rhodes]

I think it was more to do with Horace being afraid that the Herts FA saw his comments!

[Winslow Boy]

I think it was more to do with Horace being afraid that the Herts FA saw his comments!

No I think it's more to do with exactly what he said and not something that you have made up out of nowhere.

[petethegreek]

It's fraud also as they tried to gain financial income in an inappropriate manner.

Stick them in Division 2 is what the SSML should do as they have brought shame on the league, plus they're sh1t too

 

Cannot relegate them for a misdemeanor in an external Competition.

[tringarmy]

Tring had an email after we lost to Dunstable a couple of years back telling us to appeal against one of their subs. It was signed as "a friend" & came from an anonymous email account. We'd lost 6-1 and decided not to take it any further. Out of curiousity I looked into it & turned out he'd played in the Trophy rather than the Vase so was fine to play anyway.

 

Just before I joined Sun Sports they played a ringer in goal in the Vase & lost by at least 7 or 8 at Hanwell. Of all the names they could have picked the player they chose actually worked with the ref. He obviously reported it & they got banned from the Vase & FA Cup for a few seasons.

 

Amersham have played ringers before in the league, might have been last season or the one before. They were naming one on team sheets for a month after they had cancelled his Amersham registration & transferred to Tring

Edited November 24, 2012 by tringarmy

[the quite one]

From previous experience If they have been found to be doing this on a regular basis, I think the will be expelled from next seasons Vase and possibly FA Cup. But we can't really judge until amersham explain.

[Mississippi Burning]

How can they explain this away? They have been caught out blatantly trying to cheat and have been at it for some time. Why should Everyone else have to conform to rules when these jokers clearly feel they don't have to. They are Sunday league and should be sent there where they belong.

 

[Winslow Boy]

How can they explain this away? They have been caught out blatantly trying to cheat and have been at it for some time. Why should Everyone else have to conform to rules when these jokers clearly feel they don't have to. They are Sunday league and should be sent there where they belong.

Got to say I agree