Standard of refs

[pearcey no.1]

After Reading what johnnojudo has written about his games ref and if you read the report on ngu v egham it seems the the standard of res is slipping I spoke to the Wembley manager the other day and he said the ref was bad he asked the assesor what's going on with refs the assesor said it was his 1st game in the ccl.so it seems the ccl is the guinea pig for the refs,which is unfair as 1 bad decision or a booking for which could lead to a key player being banned could cost a team the league and with only 1 team going up it is critical that the man in the middle is up to scratch!

[Krooner]

Totally disagree with that statement. Remind me where Wembley are in the table ? I think their manager may need to look elsewhere for his excuses.

 

In my opinion and I know of many others who think the same I believe the standard of the refereeing in the Premier Division has improved over the last 2 or 3 years. The CCL is not a guinea pig. They get as many new refs as all leagues at this level. Perhaps I could ask this question. A Youth player shows promise so the club manager puts him in the 1st team. He has a stinker. That is it for him is it ? Never seen again ?

 

I will ignore the old chestnut about "1 bad decision". One of the most idiotic statements ever made by anyone in football !!!!

[Teflon]

Surprisingly I have to agree with........................................Krooner

[Smudge]

I can only comment on the Refs that I have seen,and having been critical in my early days on this Forum of a lack of consistentancy by Refs,I must say I feel for them now.The fault lies with their assistants,who let them down in crucial decisions.Take the Farleigh game a definite Penalty just 15 yds from Assistant,but no flag although he had best view in ground.Yet the assistant on the other side was quick to flag,when Manager complained about no decision being given.The Croydon v Croydon Mun game,2 definite offside decisions not given led to Goals,not my words those of 3 Combined Refs watching.Kroons maybe you should take in a fewer lower level games to see what people are complaining about in C.C.L.because they pay the same money,and should get the same quality of service.Saturday's game at Farleigh v Hartley should be a starter it was mentioned to me last week that Rocket Ron and Mr.G are down for running the line,so dont expect the Ref to get great reviews,and a few cards to be dished out.Refs at Badshot/Egham,R.P.V. V Camberley,were excellent and they have been good in recent games for Municipal fixtures I've seen.

[Smudge]

Totally disagree with that statement. Remind me where Wembley are in the table ? I think their manager may need to look elsewhere for his excuses.

 

In my opinion and I know of many others who think the same I believe the standard of the refereeing in the Premier Division has improved over the last 2 or 3 years. The CCL is not a guinea pig. They get as many new refs as all leagues at this level. Perhaps I could ask this question. A Youth player shows promise so the club manager puts him in the 1st team. He has a stinker. That is it for him is it ? Never seen again ?

 

I will ignore the old chestnut about "1 bad decision". One of the most idiotic statements ever made by anyone in football !!!!

 

Maradonna would agree with you there Kroons. as Teflon intimated I'm with STUPID.

[Teflon]

Totally disagree with that statement. Remind me where Wembley are in the table ? I think their manager may need to look elsewhere for his excuses.

 

In my opinion and I know of many others who think the same I believe the standard of the refereeing in the Premier Division has improved over the last 2 or 3 years. The CCL is not a guinea pig. They get as many new refs as all leagues at this level. Perhaps I could ask this question. A Youth player shows promise so the club manager puts him in the 1st team. He has a stinker. That is it for him is it ? Never seen again ?

 

I will ignore the old chestnut about "1 bad decision". One of the most idiotic statements ever made by anyone in football !!!!

 

Maradonna would agree with you there Kroons. as Teflon intimated I'm with STUPID.

 

 

[Krooner]

When will we get to meet Smudgey

 

I know plenty about Division 1 mate as I spend more of my time there than Premier games

[Big J R]

Talking of referee's..........

 

......you ought to read the write-up in this weeks Dorking Advertiser about the recent Chobham - Cobham game.

 

I bet a certain referee's ears must be really burning !!!

[Jurg78]

Can you post a link at all BJR??

[pearcey no.1]

Totally disagree with that statement. Remind me where Wembley are in the table ? I think their manager may need to look elsewhere for his excuses.

 

In my opinion and I know of many others who think the same I believe the standard of the refereeing in the Premier Division has improved over the last 2 or 3 years. The CCL is not a guinea pig. They get as many new refs as all leagues at this level. Perhaps I could ask this question. A Youth player shows promise so the club manager puts him in the 1st team. He has a stinker. That is it for him is it ? Never seen again ?

 

I will ignore the old chestnut about "1 bad decision". One of the most idiotic statements ever made by anyone in football !!!!

Idiot I am not,I'll drop this subject til I read about a bad,wrong or dodgy decision goes against you and cos you,meaning you spend another season languishing in the ccl another season without ryman football.

[Big J R]

Can you post a link at all BJR??

 

 

The article hasn't actually been posted on the web. I read it in the paper itself.

 

If you want, I'll type it out and PM it to you.

 

I have met the new Sports Editor of the Dorking Advertiser, and he definitely 'says it as he see it' !

[Jurg78]

If you wouldn't mind BJR that would be much appreciated.

[Smudge]

Smash,calm down mate it's only a game after all.But the point you made earlier is relevant.This League is no different to any other,the playing side is all about money,The Wembley Manager could get better players if he had the same budget as some,which was a poor shout by Kroons.And would Camberley v Badshot Lea get the same level of Officials,as say Croydon Municipal v Coulsdon,I think not.But where as nothing can be done about level budgets,surely as all teams pay same for Officials this should be done on a lottery basis.But it never will,why,cos like players better Officials want bigger games.

[Krooner]

Smashy wasn't suggesting you were an idiot I was suggesting that it was an idiotic statement. Had a long conversation with the AM at Camberley last season after he had a right go at me about a game when Camberley conceded a last minute equaliser due to an "alledged" poor decision. He said, at the time, that it could cost us the championship. I mentioned to him that would it not have been the fact that on at least 3 occasions Camberley had lost a 2 goal lead that had nothing to do with an officials decisions.

 

Not in 24 years of supporting the club has an officials decision cost us any cups, championships, preventing relegation. All the time is has been our inability to do or prevent any of those things happening.

 

Dont drop it because surely the board is about things like this. You give your opinion and I disagree and give a different one. Others will follow suit and do the same. Healthy debate I think they call it.

[Big J R]

If you wouldn't mind BJR that would be much appreciated.

 

 

On it's way shortly.

 

In hindsight, I reckon one of your club official probably wrote it.

[pearcey no.1]

Smashy wasn't suggesting you were an idiot I was suggesting that it was an idiotic statement. Had a long conversation with the AM at Camberley last season after he had a right go at me about a game when Camberley conceded a last minute equaliser due to an "alledged" poor decision. He said, at the time, that it could cost us the championship. I mentioned to him that would it not have been the fact that on at least 3 occasions Camberley had lost a 2 goal lead that had nothing to do with an officials decisions.

 

Not in 24 years of supporting the club has an officials decision cost us any cups, championships, preventing relegation. All the time is has been our inability to do or prevent any of those things happening.

 

Dont drop it because surely the board is about things like this. You give your opinion and I disagree and give a different one. Others will follow suit and do the same. Healthy debate I think they call it.

I love a good debate,I believe fans focus is good for everyone to share opinions,your sides finnishing ability is down to your manager and coach to sort out,1 bad decision as a statement Is wrong because these guys make several a game.

[Smudge]

Can you post a link at all BJR??

 

 

The article hasn't actually been posted on the web. I read it in the paper itself.

 

If you want, I'll type it out and PM it to you.

 

I have met the new Sports Editor of the Dorking Advertiser, and he definitely 'says it as he see it' !

 

B.J.R. not Ian Lamont by any chance at THE Dorking Advertiser.

[Krooner]

Less than the players though Smash and a number of those decisions will benefit your team.

 

2 things for Smudgey. 1 The officials get higher expenses for a Prem game than a Div 1 game and does your logic mean that all sides should start in the same round of the FA Cup as we all pay the same entry fee.

[pearcey no.1]

Less than the players though Smash and a number of those decisions will benefit your team.

 

2 things for Smudgey. 1 The officials get higher expenses for a Prem game than a Div 1 game and does your logic mean that all sides should start in the same round of the FA Cup as we all pay the same entry fee.

But the players have 10 mates to back them up unless there the Gk,the ref will either have an old guy or an over weight guy backing them up!

[Smudge]

Kroons,Have I mentioned F.A. Cup,I think not, the subject is Refs.It's nice to know that Premier Refs get more expenses,so what your saying is C.C.L. Premier clubs get better Officials because they pay more,how much more may I ask.Do Assistants get more also.I'm sure Div 1 clubs wouldn't mind paying more for better Officials,have they been made aware of this price differential.Bit like shopping at HARRODS rather than ALDI.