Final Whistle - When and Where.

[Gussy]

We had a corner against Molesey on saturday we took it and as soon as the ball was struck he blew the whistle why on earth would he do that surely he should of waited to see what transpired.

 

we might of scored

might of went for a goal kick

Throw in maybe

 

All good times imo to pipe up

[Krooner]

Ball has to be live when the final whistle is blown.

[Gussy]

So can it blown as a player is taking a pen

 

"Peep"

 

Sorry fella not enough time ha ha ha ha ha

 

Sorry very childish but Kroons ur answer is very ambigous, but i understand ur position and will not press you any further

[Krooner]

Time is allowed for the completion of the penalty kick.

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

the penalty is the only thing that time can be added on for.

 

 

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

dont players get taught the rules any more?

[Gussy]

Joke + Head + Whoosh = .......

[Krooner]

DOH !!!

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

there was a full back saturday giving the lino stick over everything

 

that was crap, how did you qualify for this job etc etc

 

he misses two headers, shanks two passes of into touch within five minutes.

 

lino doesnt give an offside and the full back is off again.

 

 

the full back was just allowed to keep on with it, no word from the captain or coach.

respect?

[Jurg78]

Wasn't there a World Cup game when that happened (think in the 70's)?!?!

 

The Welsh ref blew up as the corner game in and the attacking team (Brasil?) scored from it, but ref said that the time was up and the goal didn't count!!

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

what constitutes completion of the penalty kick?

 

goal or goal kick obviously, but what about if the keeper saves it?

 

if he catches it times up, but if he pushes it onto the post and it rebounds and hits him on the back of the head and is rolling across the line very slowly on a downhill slope with the wind behind do you allow nature to take its course?

 

I need to know for a novel im writing where Dorking play Chertsey in the fa cup final and this very event occurs.

[Terrence Collina]

my understanding is that the ball should be in a neutral zone before the final whistle is blown, but which ever way, it will cause problems. As corner taken, blow up - team might have won or equalised, wait til neutral zone - goal might get scored and team loses or draws. Tricky one.

 

In terms of the penalty, as soon as the result of the kick is know, whistle goes. If the keeper saves it and rebounds into play - hard luck the referee does not wait to see what happens to the rebound. To make his job easier, the referee should say to the players that as soon as the result of the kick is known, he will blow for time. The referees are encouraged to say this.

[Krooner]

I find it a lot easier not to give any penalties

[Gussy]

Krooner who was the ref @ Vale Farm last night he was very good!

[TRS]

Aha, memories of an FA Cup game Wimbledon v Wrexham ten years ago. 0-0 in really windy conditions into the 90th minute, Steve Dunn awards corner to Dons. Corner taken, Dunn blows his whistle just as Marcus Gayle's head meets the ball which then hits the back of the net!

 

http://www.bbc.co.uk/wales/northeast/fun/spot1/

[Jeff Hamnett TSF]

a couple of refs have done it, in very big games.its not the most intelligent thing to do. More sensible is the blowing for full time a second after the restart.

[TRS]

Originally Posted By: thespursfan

a couple of refs have done it, in very big games.its not the most intelligent thing to do. More sensible is the blowing for full time a second after the restart.

Thing is, it wasn't as if he blew as the corner taker kicked the ball - he more or less waited for it to hit Gayle's head! I clearly remember his whistle blowing as the ball was hitting the net. Fortunately, the replay was won 3-1 from memory...